The best soda maker overall in 2024 is the SodaStream Terra, which consistently makes sparkling water with a simple manual pump, is cost-effective with an exchange program for carbonation canisters, and takes up minimal counter space. The Terra model has received improvements, such as the ability to click the carbon dioxide canister into the back. While the plastic build is slightly flimsy, the Terra offers a basic package for around $100, including a carbon dioxide cartridge and plastic carafe, or a value bundle for $160 with additional accessories. For those who want more than just sparkling water, the Ninja Thirsti drink system is a suitable option at $150, offering electronic enhancements like flavors, caffeine, and vitamins in various serving sizes.
If design and aesthetics are important, the Aarke III Carbonator is a stylish option at around $200, constructed from metal and offering a vintage appeal. While it may not be the most cost-effective model, it can use SodaStream and Soda Sensei canisters with robust exchange programs. Alternatively, the SodaStream Aqua Fizz, priced at $120, features a glass carafe for a more premium feel, making it a great option for special occasions. In testing various soda water makers, factors such as general performance, ease of use, and overall value were taken into consideration. The SodaStream models were noted as the most consistent among manual machines, while the Spärkel electric seltzer maker provided precision with five unique settings.
In terms of cost savings, making seltzer at home with a soda maker can be significantly cheaper compared to store-bought options. Using the exchange program with SodaStream, one can estimate saving about 25 cents per liter of seltzer in comparison to store prices that average around 80 cents per liter. Over a year, the total cost including cartridges and the SodaStream Terra would amount to around $202, resulting in approximately 56 cents per liter, showcasing the potential savings in the long run. Additionally, soda water makers like SodaStream and Aarke Carbonator are environmentally friendly alternatives, reducing waste from cans and plastic bottles, with reusable carbon dioxide canisters.
Beyond making carbonated water, soda water makers offer the versatility of carbonating various other beverages, including fruit juices, sparkling wine, flat beer, and even milk. With the ability to add fizz to almost any liquid, these machines provide options for creating personalized and flavorful drinks at home. Overall, choosing a soda maker depends on individual preferences, such as design, functionality, and cost-effectiveness, with options like SodaStream Terra, Ninja Thirsti drink system, Aarke III Carbonator, and SodaStream Aqua Fizz catering to different needs and tastes.
