Extra-firm mattresses are essential for those who need more support while sleeping, especially if they prefer to sleep on their back or stomach. These mattresses can also benefit plus-size individuals by providing the necessary support for back pain. Given the limited options available in the market for extra-firm mattresses, CNET’s team of sleep experts has compiled a list of the best options based on extensive testing. The Plank mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is highlighted as the best overall extra-firm mattress, offering both firmness and pressure relief. The mattress is flippable, providing two firmness options in one.
Another top contender for the best extra-firm mattress is the Firm Natural mattress from Plank, which is a certified organic latex hybrid mattress endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association. Made with premium organic materials, this mattress offers a bouncy and springy feel thanks to the latex and coils. It is a great choice for strict back and stomach sleepers who prioritize environmentally friendly products. The Avocado Green mattress, a hybrid mattress with multiple firmness levels, also stands out for its exceptional spinal and lumbar support, making it ideal for those with back pain.
The Saatva Classic mattress is recommended for its unparalleled spinal and lumbar support, featuring two coil layers for added firmness and a luxury pillow top for comfort. With multiple zoned layers to provide targeted support and pressure relief, the Saatva Classic offers a luxurious feel while promoting spinal alignment. The Helix Luxe Twilight model, a premium hybrid mattress, offers a firm yet accommodating feel with added pressure relief. Backed by the ACA, this mattress is suitable for those looking for a luxury experience with firm support.
For heavier individuals, the Titan Plus Luxe mattress by Brooklyn Bedding is designed with nearly 1,000 8-inch steel coils and ultra-dense foams for proper support and durability. The Luxe model offers additional cushion in the pillow top for increased comfort, making it a worthwhile investment for heavy sleepers. Additionally, the Allswell Brick mattress, an affordable hybrid bed with an extra-firm feel, is an excellent choice for those on a budget. Made with steel coils and copper-infused memory foam, this mattress provides solid support at an affordable price point.
When shopping for an extra-firm mattress, it’s essential to consider factors such as sleeping position, body type, and budget. Extra-firm mattresses are best suited for back or stomach sleepers, as they promote spinal alignment and reduce back pain. However, side sleepers may find these mattresses uncomfortable, especially if they are petite or lightweight. Additionally, budget constraints should be taken into account when choosing a mattress, as prices can vary significantly based on the materials and construction. Ultimately, selecting the right extra-firm mattress depends on individual preferences and requirements for a good night’s sleep.
