Furious New York City business owners are angry with State Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie for his refusal to increase penalties for violent shoplifters, with some saying, “It’s open season on retail workers.” Heastie’s decision to shut down Governor Kathy Hochul’s plan to toughen sentences for criminals has sparked outrage, as many believe that penalties are necessary to deter crime. Nelson Eusebio, who heads the National Supermarket Association, emphasized the risk faced by retail workers dealing with shoplifters on a daily basis.
Incidents of criminal violence towards retail workers are increasing, with one CVS employee describing how shoplifters are becoming more brazen and violent. The employee mentioned that the store is now locking up even low-priced products, as shoplifters are taking entire shelves during their rampages. Despite the increase in thefts, the chain did not mention this as the reason for the store’s closure in May. The employee expressed frustration at the lack of action to address the issue.
Eusebio reported a 20% surge in assaults on supermarket workers this year, while citywide retail thefts have risen by more than 6.5% compared to the previous year. Governor Hochul’s proposed crackdown on retail thefts aimed to address the $4.4 billion loss that New York retailers are facing due to such crimes. However, Heastie refused to support the plan, arguing that lawmakers should focus on other strategies to address the issue.
Even former Governor David Paterson expressed shock at Heastie’s position, pointing out that harsher penalties are needed to deter criminals and provide opportunities for rehabilitation. Heastie defended his stance, suggesting that the focus should be on preventing crimes rather than relying solely on penalties. Despite this, Heastie mentioned that he is open to parts of Hochul’s plan, particularly targeting organized retail theft rings.
Retailers like Francisco Marte, president of New York’s Bodega and Small Business Association, have criticized Heastie’s lack of support for tougher penalties. Marte expressed disappointment at the speaker’s remarks and highlighted the risks faced by business owners and working-class individuals due to rising crime rates. Salvatore Lopiccolo recounted his experience as a security guard who was attacked by a shoplifter, emphasizing the need for stronger measures to prevent such incidents.
The case of former Harlem bodega clerk Jose Alba, who was charged after fatally stabbing a violent customer in self-defense, serves as a reminder of the risks faced by retail workers. Heastie’s reluctance to enhance penalties for violent shoplifters has raised concerns among business owners, with many calling for more decisive action to address the surge in criminal activity targeting retail workers. As the debate over crime and punishment continues, it remains to be seen how policymakers will respond to the growing threat to public safety and business viability in New York City.
