The New York Mets are heading into the new season with some uncertainty surrounding their first base situation. President of baseball operations David Stearns is exploring the possibility of completing a blockbuster trade for Toronto Blue Jays’ first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Despite being an All-Star for the fourth time in 2024 and winning his second Silver Slugger Award, Guerrero could be on the move if the Mets can put together an enticing trade package.
One potential trade proposal suggested by Metsmerized Online involves the Mets receiving Vladimir Guerrero Jr. in exchange for third baseman Brett Baty, first baseman/outfielder Ryan Clifford, infielder Luisangel Acuña, and right-handed pitcher Tylor Megill. This trade package would provide the Blue Jays with players who could immediately contribute to their roster, while also securing long-term potential with prospects like Clifford, who is ranked as the Mets’ fourth-best prospect with an estimated MLB arrival in 2026.
If the trade goes through, the Mets would have an elite replacement for Pete Alonso at first base for the 2025 season. However, Guerrero’s impending free agency after the upcoming season brings some uncertainty to the situation. Guerrero is estimated to earn $28.8 million in the final year of his contract, and his market value for a long-term deal is projected at 12 years and $427 million. This could pose financial challenges for the Mets if they decide to pursue a long-term extension with Guerrero.
Meanwhile, Pete Alonso, the Mets’ current first baseman, remains on the free-agent market. While re-signing with the Mets seems like the most likely scenario, negotiations have been ongoing, leaving room for other teams such as the San Francisco Giants or Seattle Mariners to potentially swoop in and secure Alonso’s services. If another team manages to sign Alonso, the Mets could pivot towards a trade for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. as a high-impact replacement at first base.
Ultimately, the decision on first base for the Mets will depend on how negotiations with Alonso unfold, as well as the potential trade discussions with the Blue Jays for Guerrero. Both Alonso and Guerrero bring significant offensive firepower to the table, and the Mets will need to weigh their options carefully to ensure they have a solid plan in place for the upcoming season. With the offseason still in full swing, it remains to be seen how the first base situation for the Mets will ultimately play out leading up to opening day.
