Elizabeth Chambers and her costars from Freeform’s Grand Cayman: Secrets in Paradise have discussed Armie Hammer multiple times throughout the show. The docusoap premiered in April, following a group of wealthy locals and newcomers in the Cayman Islands as they navigate relationships, friendships, and careers. Elizabeth, a main cast member and producer on the project, shared her side of the story, mentioning the “Cayman Curse” where couples end up separating or divorcing after moving to the island together. Elizabeth and Armie, who share two children, divorced in July 2020 after a decade of marriage.
Armie was accused in 2021 of sending graphic text messages to women detailing his sexual fantasies, including rape, mutilation, and cannibalism. He was also accused of sexual assault, which his attorneys denied. Elizabeth expressed shock and devastation about the scandal, admitting she had much to learn about delicate matters. The scandal was quickly brought up on Grand Cayman: Secrets in Paradise due to Elizabeth and Armie’s history in the Cayman Islands. Armie apologized to Elizabeth in 2023 for his past infidelity but has not publicly addressed the reality series.
Elizabeth discussed her painful divorce from Armie on the show, calling it a traumatic and public experience that shattered the life they had planned for years. She expressed readiness for a fresh start on the island, leaving behind the trauma of the past two years. While Elizabeth preferred not to speak about Armie, her costars shared their opinions and insights on her behavior post-divorce, implying a reluctance to portray moving on quickly in the public eye. Accusations involving Armie and his alleged involvement with other women were also discussed by cast members.
In one episode, a cast member, Courtney McTaggart, mentioned being accused of being involved with Armie before his divorce, leading to receiving horrible messages from fake accounts on Instagram. Alleged receipts from Courtney implying Elizabeth’s involvement in the attacks were mentioned, but Elizabeth denied any knowledge of the situation. The first episode ended with the cast reading Armie’s tell-all interview where Elizabeth was portrayed in a negative light, causing further controversy and speculation among the cast members. Elizabeth maintained her focus on her children amid the scandal, with both her and Armie addressing the accusations in their own ways.
Armie clarified in his interview that he was taking accountability for his past actions and mistakes, emphasizing the need to own up to being selfish and treating people poorly. When asked about her thoughts on the controversy, Elizabeth declined to engage, stating that only she knows the truth and that unless someone was there, they don’t understand the full story. The ongoing discussions and revelations surrounding Armie and Elizabeth’s relationship and the scandal have played out on Freeform’s Grand Cayman: Secrets in Paradise, offering viewers a glimpse into the personal lives of the cast members, including their reactions and perspectives on the unfolding events.
